Last September, we spent 5 days and 5 nights each in
Paris and Berlin. It was our second trip to Paris – our first was in 1975 – and
first to Berlin. Both cities have very interesting dynamics relating to life
there during the 1930s and 1940s, most notably the rule by the Nazis.
Arc de Triomphe and Brandenburg Gate
For years, even decades, Jews have avoided traveling to
Germany, for the memories of Nazi horrors still stood either fresh in memories
or had been handed down to subsequent generations. It was the same mindset that
prevented people from buying German-manufactured automobiles. Now, almost 75
years after the fall of Nazi regime, those barriers have mostly fallen, in part
because of the German people taking unflinching responsibility for the actions
of their government and people.
After returning from our trip, a relative remarked he
found Berlin a bit “creepy,” although it had been a few years since he had been
there. I responded I’d tried to keep from dwelling on what was as opposed to
what is now. In addition, the only Nazi government building still standing is the
Reichsluftfahrtministerium (Ministry of Aviation), a Brutalist building housing
the German Finance Ministry. Hitler’s bunker is below a nondescript surface
parking lot, and all other Nazi buildings were either destroyed by Allied
bombings or postwar demolitions. The most interesting parts of the city turned
out to be in the former East Berlin rather than in West Berlin.
Reichsluftfahrtministerium (Ministry of Aviation)
Berlin has three major sites in the city featuring
education about the Jews of German and the Holocaust. Best known are The
Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe and Information Centre, also known as
the Holocaust Memorial; Topography of Terror; and the Jewish Museum of Berlin. The
Memorial to the Sinti and Roma Victims of National Socialism, near the
Reichstag, also honors those murdered simply for being who they were. All
provide extensive commentary on this terrible era. Plaques in the Jewish
Quarter and the Neue Synagogue provide additional information about the era.
The
Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe
Topography of Terror
Jewish Museum of Berlin
The Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe, also known
as the Holocaust Memorial, was designed by architect Peter Eisenman and
engineer Buro Happold. Its 200,000 square-foot site is covered with 2,711
concrete slabs, arranged in a grid pattern on a sloping field. Organized in
rows, 54 go north–south and 87 go east–west at right angles but set slightly
askew. Construction began in April 2003 and was finished in late 2004. It was
inaugurated on May 10, 2005, sixty years after the end of World War II in
Europe. It is located one block south of the Brandenburg Gate.
The
Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe (Reichstag in background)
The Information Centre, located beneath the Memorial,
begins with a timeline for the
Final
Solution from when the
Nazis
took power in 1933 through the murder of 500,000 Soviet Jews in 1941. The rest
of the exhibition is divided into four rooms dedicated to personal aspects of
the tragedy: individual families or letters thrown from the
trains
that transported them to the
death camps. The Room of Families focuses on
the fates of 15 specific Jewish families. In the Room of Names, names of all
known Jewish Holocaust victims obtained from the
Yad Vashem
memorial are read out loud. Each chamber contains visual reminders of the
stelae above: rectangular benches, horizontal floor markers and vertical
illuminations.
Information Centre
The Jewish Museum Berlin is the largest Jewish museum in
Europe. It consists of three buildings, two of which are new additions
specifically built for the museum by
architect
Daniel Libeskind. The W. Michael Blumenthal
Academy of the Jewish Museum Berlin was built – also after a design by
Libeskind – adjacent to the building in 2011 and 2012 in the former flower
market hall. The archives, library, museum education department, lecture hall
and Diaspora Garden are located here. The museum essentially consists of two buildings
– a baroque old building, the
“Kollegienhaus”
(that formerly housed the Berlin Museum), and a new,
deconstructivist-style
building by Libeskind. The two buildings have no visible connection above
ground. The 161,000 square-foot Libeskind building contains twisted passages
and is accessible only via an underground entrance from the old building.
Construction on the new extension to the museum began in November 1992. The
empty museum was completed in 1999 and attracted more 350,000 people before it
was filled and opened in September 2001.
Jewish Museum of Berlin
The Topography of Terror is located on the site of
buildings that housed the
SS Reich Main Security Office, the headquarters of the
Sicherheitspolizei,
SD,
Einsatzgruppen
and
Gestapo.
The Gestapo and SS headquarters buildings were largely destroyed by Allied
bombing during early 1945; the ruins were demolished after the war. The
boundary between the American and Soviet zones of occupation ran along
Prinz-Albrecht-Strasse; thus the street soon became a fortified boundary. The
Berlin Wall
ran along the south side of Niederkirchnerstrasse. The wall here was never
demolished. The section adjacent to the Topography of Terror is the longest
extant segment of the outer wall.
Topology of Terror
The first exhibitions on the site took place in 1987, as
part of Berlin's 750th anniversary. The cellar of the Gestapo headquarters,
where many political prisoners were tortured and executed, was found and
excavated. The site was then turned into an open-air memorial and museum,
protected from the elements by a canopy, detailing the history of Nazi
repression. A joint exhibition was shown both at the site and in East Germany
in 1989. In 1993, three years after
German reunification, a foundation established to take care of
the site chose architect
Peter
Zumthor to design a permanent museum. However, construction was
stopped due to funding problems after the concrete core of the structure had
been built, which stood on the site for nearly a decade until it was demolished
in 2004 and a new building begun. Construction of the new Documentation Center by
architect Ursula Wilms and landscape architect Heinz W. Hallmann was finished
in 2010.
Topology of Terror
Paris, mainly thanks to German Gen. Dietrich von
Cholititz, who defied Hitler’s directive to totally destroy the city in August
1944 before the Allies retook Paris (leading to the famous question, “Is Paris
burning?”), still looks like one huge movie set. Beneath it lies the ugly
history of Nazi occupation, aided in large part by collaborators and the Vichy
State in southern France. I found thoughts about the former Nazi headquarters I
photographed, as well as historic photographs of SS officers lounging on the Champs-Élysées
and the Nazi flag flying atop the Eiffel Tower, to be as unnerving as any I
would have in Berlin.
Paris (from Centre Pompidou observation deck)
While reading Madame Foucade’s Secret War, the biography
of the woman who led France’s largest spy ring during World War II, I jotted
down address of Paris buildings that housed Nazi operation to photograph during
our trip. Three of them our now luxury hotels; another is a government
building. The most notorious of all – 84 Avenue Foch, the headquarters for SD,
SS counterintelligence – where prisoners were tortured and murdered was a bit
too far out of our way.
The Peninsula Paris, opened in 1908 as the Hotel Majestic,
served as the headquarters of the German military high command in France during
the
German
occupation from October 1940 to July 1944.
Formerly the site of the palace of Queen Isabella II of Spain, hotelier Leonard
Tauber constructed the Hotel Majestic, retaining Queen Isabella's bathroom
accoutrements, including her marble bath, in the Presidential suite. Designed
by Armand Sibien, construction began in 1906 and was completed in 1908. The
hotel was purchased for use as a military hospital at the outbreak of
World War I
and served in this capacity for five months. It was damaged during its hospital
service and was not renovated and reopened until 1916. It was purchased by the
French
government in 1936 to serve as offices for the
Ministry of Defence . After the war, The
Majestic served as the first headquarters of UNESCO
until 1958, when
it was converted into a conference center for The
Organization
for Economic Co-operation and Development, founded
at the hotel in 1960. It was also the location for the signing of the
Paris Peace Accords on January 27, 1973, ending
American involvement in the
Vietnam War. The French government sold the
building in 2008 to Qatari Diar for $460 million. It reopened on August 1,
2014. The hotel offers 200 luxury rooms, including 34 suites, ranging from $750
to more than $1,000 a night.
Peninsula Paris
Le Scribe, down the street from the Opéra Garnier, was
constructed by Baron Haussmann in 1861. During World War II, the hotel served
as the German communications center. After the liberation of Paris, the Allied
forces established its press center here. Now the Sofitel Le Scribe Paris
Opéra, it was the home of the original Jockey Club.
Sofitel Le Scribe Paris
Opéra
11 Rue des Saussaies was Gestapo headquarters for
occupied Paris during World War II. After the war, the building housed the
Ministry of the Interior, including the
Sûreté nationale.
11 Rue des Sassaies
I did not have the correct address for the Hotel Meurice on
the Rue de Rivoli but found it as part of a wide-angle photograph. The hotel opened in 1815. Between September 1940 and August 1944,
the hotel was requisitioned by the German occupation authorities. In August
1944, the Meurice became the headquarters of General
Dietrich von Choltitz, the military
governor of Paris. As noted earlier, von Choltitz famously disobeyed Hitler's
commands to level the city of Paris. Hitler's reported screamed to von Choltitz
over a Hotel Meurice telephone, "Is Paris burning?" Rooms now go for more
than $1,000 a night.
Hotel Meurice (domed building to the left)
Another building with World War II significance is the
Hotel Saint-Florentin, completed in 1769. The hotel was acquired by James de
Rothschild in 1838; it was renovated during the 1860s. The family rented it to
the United States Government in 1948, where it was used to administer the
Marshall Plan and later the George Marshall Center. The United States purchased
the building in 1950; now most of the building is leased to the Jones Day law
firm. The Marshall Center remains as part of the Hotel de Tallyrand.
Hotel Saint-Florentin
This is not to say there are no acknowledgements of the
Nazi occupation in Paris. Two sites in particular memorize those lost in the
Holocaust.
The Memorial to the Martyrs of the Deportation honors the
200,000 people who were sent from
Vichy France
to
Nazi concentration and death camps. Located on the site of a former
morgue,
it was designed by
architect Georges-Henri Pingusson and inaugurated in
1962. The memorial is shaped like a ship's
prow; the crypt is
accessible by two staircases and a lowered square. The crypt leads to a
hexagonal rotunda that includes two chapels containing earth and bones from
concentration camps. The memorial's narrow entrance is marked by two concrete
blocks. Along both walls of the narrow, dimly lit chamber, 200,000 glass
crystals
with light shining through symbolize each deportees who died in the camps; a
single bright light is located at the end of the tunnel. Urns with ashes from
the camps are positioned at both lateral ends. The chamber’s ends have small
rooms that seem to depict prison cells. An iron gate opposite the entrance overlooks
the
Seine
at the tip of the
Île de la Cité. A circular plaque on the floor
of the underground chamber reads: "They descended into the mouth of the
earth and they did not return." A "flame of eternal hope" burns
and The Tomb of the Unknown Deportee bears the inscription: "Dedicated to
the living memory of the 200,000 French deportees sleeping in the night and the
fog, exterminated in the Nazi concentration camps."
Memorial to the Martyrs of the Deportation
Because of time constraints, we were only able to pass The
Memorial of the Shoah, which opened near the Jewish Quarter in 2005. The
forecourt of the memorial includes a circular memorial listing the names of the
death camps and the Warsaw Ghetto. There is also a wall with seven bas-reliefs
by Arbit Blatas that symbolize the camps and the persecution of the Jews.
Several walls that make a passageway to the building list the names of the
approximately 76,000 French Jews who were deported and murdered by the Nazis.
The crypt predates the Memorial of the Shoah; in 1957, the ashes of victims
from the different death camps and the Warsaw Ghetto were buried in dirt from
Israel. The crypt also includes a door from the Warsaw Ghetto and the
"Jewish Files" created by the Vichy government to identify Jewish
citizens. These files were later used by the Nazis to locate Jews for
deportation. Some 3,300 persons awarded the title "Righteous Among the
Nations" to non-Jewish people who helped save Jews during the war have
their names listed on the wall that runs alongside of the memorial.


Museum of the Shoah
Finally, plaques in the Jewish Quarter in the Marais
District commemorate those deported from Paris as part of the Final Solution.
And as a reminder that anti-Semitism never disappears, the bombing and shooting
attack at Chez Jo Goldenberg restaurant on August 9, 1982, was carried out by
the
Abu Nidal Organization, a group that
splintered from
Fatah.
Two assailants threw a grenade into the dining room, then rushed in and fired
machine guns. Six people, including two Americans, were killed and 22 were
injured. The restaurant closed in 2006 and former owner Jo Goldenberg died in
2014.
Former Chez Jo Goldenberg